The Three-Minute ETS Consultation
First -Grader Version
If you don't even have 3 minutes, check out this explanation and diagram that could have been done by a 6 year old!
by songboy1234

In defense of their advertising websites and other promotional tools which offer incomplete information at best, some ETS surgeons have made remarks such as

"This is just a brief introduction to ETS. I explain the effects of the surgery in great detail during the patient consultation."
But how long does it really take, and how hard is it to give the full picture? Actual patient consent forms, such as this one from Addenbrooke Hospital in Cambridge, would suggest that many ETS surgeons do not ever explain sympathectomy fully to their patients. Below is an explanation that takes only about 3 minutes, and which I feel would convey a reasonable amount of information for a patient to make an informed decision.

Dear patient, you are presenting with a cosmetic problem. While your excessive sweating (blushing) is embarrassing to you, and may cause you to dislike or avoid social situations, and this can indeed have a negative impact on your quality of life, it is important that you understand that your condition is not physically harmful to you in any way.

In order to treat this, since you find oral and topical medications ineffective, we are proposing to do a sympathectomy. This means we are going to kill some of your sympathetic nerves. If we do that, you will notice several permanent changes.

First and foremost, draw an imaginary line all the way around your body, right at the level of your nipples. Above that line, including the arms, hands, upper back, chest, face and scalp, you may never sweat again. Not from heat, not from exercise, never. This is called anhidrosis, and while some people tolerate it, other people find the extreme dryness to be very uncomfortable, especially in the hands and scalp.

Below the imaginary line, in areas such as the belly, lower back, and crotch, you will most likely sweat much more than before. This is called compensatory hyperhidrosis, and again, some people tolerate it while others find it disturbing, even disabling. Compensatory hyperhidrosis can be severe enough to soak through clothing. It may require oral or topical medication (the same medications you currently find ineffective) or it may require that you wear dark clothing to hide the sweat. Please look at this:

Furthermore, dear patient, the same nerves which go to your sweat glands also lead to many other body parts. If you have this surgery, you may have a lowered heart rate, reduced cardiac strength, and lowered blood pressure. You may notice that your heart does not respond as strongly to emotion and exercise. The blood vessels in your upper body may be unable to constrict and dilate. Your bronchial tubes may not open as wide, and you may notice a loss of goose bumps and the pleasurable “chills” sensation that goes with them. You may develop a tingling or sweating reaction to eating certain foods. You may begin to lose your hair prematurely, and the skin on your upper body may be 10-12 degrees hotter than the skin below.

The combination of all these changes may cause you to be intolerant of hot and cold weather, to have a diminished exercise capacity, to be more easily fatigued, and to have reduced alertness. As a result, you may need to alter your lifestyle and/or career, especially if they involve warm-weather activities.

If we accidentally damage too much nerve tissue, you may develop “Horner’s Syndrome”, which is a drooping eyelid, a constricted pupil, and a dry sore red sunken eyeball. Or, you may suffer chronic pain in the ribs or between the shoulder blades.

As with any surgery, there is a danger of bleeding, infection, or complications from anesthesia.

While there is much that we know about sympathectomy, there is still much that we don't know. For instance, the sympathetic nerves lead to the thyroid gland, and help regulate fat burning and immune function, but what any of these mean to you in terms of long term health consequences, we simply don't know. There are scientific studies being done right now, including at the National Institutes of Health, and if you have the surgery you may be eligible to participate.

The bottom line is this: Many ETS patients are satisfied with the cosmetic results, and tolerate the physical changes well. Other ETS patients do not tolerate them well at all, and consider themselves to be permanently disabled. If you elect to have the surgery, this is the risk you will take.

I believe it is clear that very few patients would elect to have ETS if it was explained this way. This is what I call "the surgeon's dilemma".

discuss this article
The First-Grader Version
You will not be able to sweat at all from the red area. The head alone is responsible for nearly half of the heat released from the body. When it's hot, you sweat a lot from below the red area, but still can't sweat from the red area. When you are cold or excited, you will not get goose bumps in the red area. Oh, and, many other things may not work right, like your heart, lungs and blood vessels. I know there are other things to tell, but I'm only 6. Would you like ETS?
thanks to Sleepy McV for the first-grader version
back to top